Melbourne School of Land and Environment Department of Forest and Ecosystem Science

 

Photo: Greenhouse Project

DSE Research Project 1.2

Bushfire CRC Projects

1 July 2006 - 30 June 2010

Project Managers: Dr Alan York, Dr Kevin Tolhurst, Dr Tina Bell

Project Overview
DFES Staff
Partners and Collaborators
HIghlights
Milestones
Publications
Presentations/Conferences
Other Outputs
Contact

Project Objectives and Background

The Bushfire CRC was formed in 2003 to carry out research into a suite of issues relating to bushfires.  Researchers in the DFES Fire Ecology and Management Group lead the following projects:

Project A4: Bushfire Risk Management Model – Dr Kevin Tolhurst

Project B2.2: Smoke composition and impact on human health and ecosystems – Dr Tina Bell

Project B3.1: The effect of fire on ecosystem processes and biodiversity – Dr Alan York

A4.1 Bushfire Risk Management Model

The overall objective of the Bushfire Risk Management sub-program is:
To develop a risk management decision support system for communities living in the rural-urban interface, town planners, power supply companies, fire fighters and land managers.

There is currently no bushfire risk management system in the world.  Fire managers have resorted to the use of “Threat Analysis” and work environment risk management, but not to the overall management of risks associated with bushfires.  Risk assessment must be assessed in terms of the potential consequences to environmental, economic and social values.  Bushfire risk management must incorporate the complex interactions between the dynamic fire environment, the complex ecological environment and the complex and politically sensitive social and economic environments.  Nobody in the world has yet been able to develop such a holistic approach to Bushfire Risk Management.

The first component of the Bushfire Risk Management Model is a clear definition of the Bushfire Management Business Model.  This includes the array of management objectives, the social, political, environmental, economic, and operational context of bushfire management and a mathematical definition of how all these factors interact.  An in-depth survey of senior fire managers from around Australia provided the basis for this model.  This model will then become the basis for the business of Bushfire Management, i.e. mitigation, in the Bushfire Risk Management Model.  A demonstration version of this model has been produced.  An automated process to revise and customise the nature of the interactions in the model is yet to be developed.

The second component of the Bushfire Risk Management Model is the fire characterisation model.  The interim version of this model has been called PHOENIX.  This is a fire spread simulation which records the frequency, intensity, size and time from ignition to impact of fires in a landscape under specified weather and ignition scenarios.  The fire characteristics across the landscape are altered by the decisions made in the Bushfire Management Business Model (mitigation scenario).  The output from this model can then be used in the third component of the system, the Bushfire Impact Model.

The Bushfire Impact Model is yet to be developed.  It is envisaged that the impact model will be used at a broad level – i.e. the impact fire will have on townships, water catchments, major elements of infrastructure, fauna and flora populations or communities, etc., rather than individual houses, powerpoles, plants or animals.  The output from the model will be expressed in terms of the probability of particular outcomes such as the probability of local extinction of a specific species, the probability of a township suffering the loss of 1, 10 or 100 houses, etc..

 

Project B2.2 Smoke composition and impact on human health and ecosystems

Smoke contains a complex mixture of visible products of burning (particulates and water vapour) and gaseous components including CO2, O3, CH4, NOX, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Most of the information relating to the composition of smoke comes from studies of industrial emissions, tobacco smoke, smoke from residential fireplaces and burning of biomass under controlled laboratory conditions. Fewer studies have determined the composition of smoke from vegetation fires but relevant information is increasing as large-scale wildfires become more prevalent and prescribed burning becomes a more important tool for land managers. The composition of smoke produced will differ depending on the type and condition of fuel, weather conditions and fire behaviour. Certain types and amounts of gases and particulates are formed during flaming combustion while others are released during the smouldering stage. Fires of low intensity tend to produce more particulate emissions than fires of higher intensities and smouldering combustion produces more CO and particulates than flaming combustion. Carbon monoxide, CH3Cl, CH3Br and CH3I, together with NH2, amines and nitriles are formed predominantly in the smouldering stage while nitrogen oxides such as NO, NO2, N2O and molecular N2 are released during flaming combustion.

While regular prescribed or fuel reduction fires may be a perceived method in which the severity of wildfires can be controlled, the impact of the smoke produced on the community may be as great as or greater than that produced by occasional wildfires. With the ability to predict the behaviour and dispersion of smoke plumes the potential risks to human health can be better communicated and therefore potentially minimised. To get to this point we need to know if the smoke produced by prescribed fires differs from that produced by wildfires. This project will help by contributing to a system to predict the composition of smoke from different fuel types and burning conditions. In addition, this project will extend to identifying the impact of smoke on human health. The ecological and environmental considerations of smoke will also be addressed.

 

Project B3.1 The effects of fire on ecosystem processes and biodiversity

Low intensity fires are used extensively in managed sclerophyll forests in Australia and there is growing concern that inappropriate fire regimes may have a negative influence on plant and animals communities.  This project seeks to model nutrient fluxes under different fire regimes, investigating the roles played by mycorrhizal and decomposer fungi and their inter-relationships with plants and invertebrates, and the likely impacts on ecosystem processes and carbon cycling. It has a focus on biodiversity; specifically
looking at functional groups of organisms and how they interact with the processes that determine productivity and ecosystem function (specifically nutrient cycling and carbon flux) and how fire interacts with these processes. This knowledge is essential for the sustainable management of Australian forests; a limited resource contributing substantially to biodiversity conservation, water catchment protection, and the provision of timber and other forest products.

A significant issue for land managers is the implication of both wildfire and hazard reduction burning for Ecologically Sustainable Management (ESM). Maintaining biodiversity and the integrity of ecological functions involves addressing problems associated with vegetation regeneration and succession, soil physical, chemical and biological properties, the conservation of biological diversity at different scales (genetic, species & ecosystem), and the role of soil flora & fauna in soil processes & nutrient cycling.  This project has 3 main components, each focussed on long-term ecological research sites:

The Bulls Ground Frequent Fire Effects Study (NSW)
The Eden Burning Study Area (NSW)
The Wombat Fire Effects Study (Vic)
The Wildfire Chronosequence Project (Tas)

Integrated, multi-disciplinary research projects are being conducted at each of these sites to address a range of issues associated with the impacts of fire management on biodiversity and ecosystem processes.

top of page

DFES Staff and Students

Project A4.1
Dr Kevin Tolhurst, Senior Lecturer, Project Leader
Derek Chong, Research Fellow

Project B2.2
Dr Tina Bell, Senior Research Fellow, Project Leader

Project B3.1
Dr Alan York, Senior Research Fellow, Project Leader
Dr Fiona Christie, Research Fellow
Catherine Nield, Research Assistant

Project Partners and Collaborators

Department of Sustainability and Environment, Fire & Emergency Management
Department of Sustainability and Environment, Land Stewardship and Biodiversity
Bushfire CRC
Parks Victoria
Tasmanian Fire Service

Highlights

back to top

2008/2009 Milestones

A4.1  Bushfire Risk Management Model

  • Conduct a two-day workshop with User Group representatives.
  • Revise fire spread simulator on basis of User Group trials.
  • Test the performance of the fire spread simulator in a range of conditions against real fires.
  • Incorporate a wind-modification factor into the fire spread algorithm to account for the effect of topography on wind speed and direction.
  • Distribute a revised version of PHOENIX software to User Group representatives.
  • Develop a trial version of PHOENIX to work on a standalone server connected to FireWeb and be available to a wider user group.
  • Develop a display and reporting environment for comparative fire impacts for various fire management scenarios. (Subject to appointment of Software Programmer).
  • Use a number of documented case-studies of livestock losses to develop a fire impact model for livestock.
  • Develop a fire suppression algorithm for a single fire that includes the effect of fire intensity, terrain, fuel type, roading and suppression type (completed for single fire, by not fully dynamic).  (Subject to appointment of Software Programmer).
  • Develop a dynamic model of suppression resource availability and travel time.
  • Develop a multi-fire, multi-weather scenario fire characterization model for a single time period.  (Subject to appointment of Software Programmer).
  • Develop a seasonal context for a sequence of fires within a season to simulate seasonal fire characteristics.
  • Develop daily weather profile for a fire season model that is based on broad seasonal characteristics.
  • Develop an interface between the Bushfire Management Business Model and the Fire Characterization Model.
  • Develop an interactive program for group development of Bushfire Management Business model parametization.  (Subject to appointment of Software Programmer).
  • Run a training session for DSE / NEO staff likely to use the web-based version of PHOENIX (Fire Behaviour Analysts)

B2.2 Smoke composition and impact on human health and ecosystems

  • Analysis of VOC production in smoke from different fuel types under a range of fuel and combustion conditions
  • Preparation of manuscripts for submission to peer-reviewed journals
  • Completion of nutrient loss project - analyses, data and manuscript preparation
  • Fire Notes, oral and poster presentations at various conferences and workshops

B3.1  The effects of fire on ecosystem processes and biodiversity

  • Submission of manuscript on effects of fire on food-web structure and biodiversity in Buttongrass Mooreland
  • Submission of manuscripts on a number of components of the Bulls Ground Frequent Burning Study
  • Submission of manuscript on herbivore-predator interaction study
  • Production of summary document, documenting and integrating research findings for Bulls Ground Frequent Burning Study
  • Fire Notes, oral and poster presentations at various conferences and workshops

back to top

Project Output - Publications

Project A4.1

Conference Papers

  • Tolhurst, K., Chong, D. and Strandgard, M. (2006) Wildfire risk management model for strategic management. Proceedings of the 5th International conference on Forest Fire Research, pg 1 - 15, Elsevier (Amsterdam)

Reports

  • Report on upgrade of fire suppression module in Phoenix based on results from Grampians fire and Wilson’s Promontory fire 2007.

  • Report on interim fire impact model for house loss based on results from Grampians, Brisbane Ranges, Stawell and Snake Valley fires 2007.

Scientific publications

  • Tolhurst, K.G. (2009) Freak or Frequency – Australia’s bushfire risk. “Beyond PML: Frequency vs. Severity”, Proceedings of a Conference sponsored by AON Benfield Australia Limited. (Peer reviewed paper). 12 pp. (in press).


Project B2.2

Peer reviewed publications

  • Bell TL, Adams MA (2007) Smoke from wildfires and prescribed burning in Australia: effects on human health and ecosystems. In: Forest Fires and Air Pollution Issues, Bytnerowicz A, Arbaugh M, Andersen C, Riebau A, editors, Developments in Environmental Science Series, Elsevier
  • Maleknia SD, Bell TL, Adams MA (2007) PTR-MS analysis of reference and plant-emitted volatile organic compounds. International Journal of Mass Spectrometry 262: 203-210.
  • Oliveras I, Bell TL (2008) An analysis of the Australian literature on prescribed burning. Journal of Forestry.106: 1. pp. 31-37.(abstract)

Reports/Reviews

  • Literature review: Techniques for sampling bushfire smoke
    • Review of analytical methods and equipment used in collection and analysis of atmospheric emissions and their relevance to bushfire smoke.

Student theses/reports

  • Catherine Stephenson (2006) 'Losses and gains of nutrients from combustion of fuels from Eucalyptus delegatensis (Alpine ash) forests'. Honours Thesis, The University of Melbourne.
  • Vicky Aerts, (2006) 'Losses and gains of nutrients from combustion of fuels from Eucalyptus pilularis (Coastal blackbutt) forests'. Overseas Student Internship Project Report.
  • Andrew Ackland, (2006) 'Regeneration of high elevation eucalypts (Eucalyptus delegatensis R.T. Baker and Eucalyptus pauciflora Sieb. ex Spreng.) after fire'. Honours Thesis, The University of Melbourne.

Project B3.1

Peer reviewed papers

  • Christie, F.J. and York, A.(in press) No effect of frequent burning on foliage nutrients and insect herbivory in an Australian eucalypt forest. Forest Ecology and Management
  • Karl E.C. Brennan, Fiona J. Christie and Alan York (in preparation) Global climate change and litter decomposition: A synergistic effect from more frequent fires with altered invertebrate assemblages retards litter decomposition

Scientific publications

  • Christie, F.J & York, A. (2009) No effect of frequent burning on foliar C and N content or insect herbivory in an Australian eucalypt forest.  Applied Vegetation Science 12: 376-384.
  • Brennan, K.E.C., Christie, F.J. & York, A. (2009)  Global climate change and litter decomposition: A synergistic effect from altered fire regimes combined with modified invertebrate assemblages slows litter decomposition.  Global Change Biology (early view).
  • Penman, T.D., Binns, D.L., Kavanagh, R.P., 2009. Patch occupancy modelling as a method for monitoring changes in forest floristics:  A case study in south-eastern Australia. Conservation Biology 23, 740-749.
  • Penman, T.D., Penman, S.H., 2009. Influence of prescribed burning on fruit production in Proteaceae. Pacific Conservation Biology 15.

back to top

Conference Presentations

Project A4.1

  • Tolhurst, K.G., Chong, D.M., Pitts, A. (2007) Phoenix – a dynamic fire characterization simulation tool. Paper presented to the Bushfire CRC Fire Behaviour Workshop, Hobart, Tasmania, September 2007. 24pp.
  • Slijepcevic, A., Tolhurst, K.G., Saunder, G., Whight, S., and Marsden-Smedley, J. (2007) A prescribed burning risk assessment tool. AFAC Conference, Hobart, Tasmania, September 2007. 5pp.

Project B3.1

  • York, A. (2008) Oral presentation at International Bushfire Research Conference (Fire, Environment and Society), Adelaide, 1st-3rd September 2008.  “Different strokes for different folks: The challenge of managing fire regimes for whole of biodiversity conservation”
  • Penman, T., York, A. and Christie, F.J. (2008) Oral presentation at International Bushfire Research Conference (Fire, Environment and Society), Adelaide, 1st-3rd September 2008.  “Prescribed burning: how can it work to conserve the things that we value?” (Alan York and Fiona Christie)
  • Christie, F.J.(2007) Oral presentation at Tasmanian Fire Conference a joint AFAC/CRC meeting in Hobart, September 07. “The effects of frequent burning on nutrient cycling and insect herbivory: implications for forest health”
  • Christie, F.J.(2007) Poster presentation Ecological Society of Australia Conference, Perth, November 2007. “The effects of fire on invertebrate food web structure in the buttongrass moorlands of Tasmania”
  • Christie, F.J.(2007) Symposium organiser “Prescribed Burning…. Now and Then”. The Ecological Society of Australia Conference, Perth, November, 2007

back to top

Other Knowledge Transfer

Project A4.1

  • User training for the use of Phoenix with small representative group from each State.
  • Successfully incorporated active spotfire development in PHOENIX.
  • Participated in fire modeling workshops in Missoula (USA) and Edmonton (Canada) and formed strong links for future collaboration.
  • Used PHOENIX to demonstrate the effects of prescribed burning on fire characteristics in the Deans Marsh fire, Otways 1983 for presentation to DSE and AFAC Rural Land Managers Group.
  • KT 28/8/2007 “Learning from Recent Victorian Fires”, Bushfire CRC Public Forum CRC Stawell, ~60 people.
  • KT 6/6/2007 “Learning from Recent Victorian Fires”, Bushfire CRC Public Forum, Wangaratta, ~60 people.

Project B2.2

  • Grape and Wine Research and Development Corporation Technical Industry Workshop on Smoke Taint (29 July, Melbourne, attendance and presentation)
  • Bushfire CRC (CRC for Fire, Environment and Society) rebid meeting (18-19 August, Melbourne, attendance and Interim Project Leader)
  • Research Working Group 6 Annual Meeting (30 August, Adelaide, attendance and handing over of Chair, knowledge transfer with agency updates)
  • Meeting with Mick Meyer, Fabienne Riesen and Bob Leicester in Aspendale about ‘smoke projects’ (13 May 2008)
  • Presented update of project B2.2 at the AFAC Rural Land Managers meeting in Melbourne (27 May 2008)
  • Tina Bell presented at the 22nd Biannual Meeting of IUFRO Research Group 7.01 (Impacts of Air Pollution and Climate Change on Forest Ecosystems) in Riverside, United States in September 2006.
  • Rachel Tham, report prepared as part of the Victorian Public Health Placement Scheme: ''Bushfire smoke and human health: what types of information are available in Victoria, Australia?' a

Project B3.1

  • Hosted Dr Scott Stephens (University of California, Berkeley) for three days at Creswick (16-18 June 2008)
  • Field Day and information session, Wombat Forest Fire Effects Study Area with Uni Melb staff and visiting CRC Colleagues
  • Alan York - CRC Steering Committee meeting Hobart 29th October 2007
  • Christie, F.C.(2007) Poster presentation, Buttongrass Workshop, Hobart, July 07. “The effects of fire on decomposer and herbivore food webs in the Buttongrass moorlands”
  • Christie, F.C.(2007) Oral presentation at Forests NSW monthly seminar series, July 07. “Effects of frequent burning on nutrient cycling and ecological processes in Eucalyptus pilularis forests”
  • Alan York, Kevin Tolhurst and Fiona Christie attended and presented at the 3rd International Fire Ecology and Management Congress (Changing Fire Regimes: Context and Consequences) in San Diego, United States in November 2006.

Cross project activities

  • Presented project results at two Bushfire CRC meetings:
    1. Fire Managers Research Meeting in Wollongong in July 2006
    2. AFAC/Bushfire CRC Annual meeting in Melbourne in August 2006
  • Presentations to prescribed Burning Courses (Gippsland and Creswick), Fire Planning Officer Training Course, Situations Officer Training Course, Operations Training Course and Fuel Assessment Training
  • Rod Keenan presented at the National Bushfire Symposium, Parliament House, Canberra in February 2007.
  • Rod Keenan attended Bushfire CRC Stakeholders meeting, April 2007.
  • Presentations to prescribed Burning Courses (Gippsland and Creswick), Fire Planning Officer Training Course, Situations Officer Training Course, Operations Training Course and Fuel Assessment Training

  • Report on the effect of fire history on fire severity for the Grampians, Moondara and Brisbane Ranges fires in 2006 and 2003 fires
  • Provision of ‘on call’ advice

back to top

Contact

Dr Alan York
Department of Forest & Ecosystem Science
Melbourne School of Land and Environment
University of Melbourne
Water St Creswick VIC 3363
Phone: +61 (0) 3 5321 4270
Fax: +61 (0) 3 5321 4166
E-mail: alan.york@unimelb.edu.au

 

back to top

 

 

top of page